www.ambiente.us JULY / JULIO 2008
Log Cabin Republicans: One Party Strategy Won't Work
Log Cabin Republicans president explains that Republican support is critical to the LGBT
movement.
by Patrick Sammon
As president of Log Cabin Republicans, the nation's largest
organization of Republicans who support freedom and fairness for
gays and lesbians, I'm not frightened easily. As any gay Republican
can attest, there is a sense of fearlessness that comes with
dispelling myths and assumptions-namely, that being gay and
Republican is somehow an oxy-moron. - Patrick Sammon, LCR
However, as I look to the future political landscape for the LGBT
community, one thing scares me-just a little. It frightens me to
think that some supporters of gay and lesbian equality will
attempt to go down the failed path of pursuing a one-party
strategy toward achieving equality.
REPUBLICAN VOTES ARE NEEDED
As history has shown, particularly in the last fifteen years, the fight for gay and lesbian equality will never be
achieved without Republican votes. We will never reach the goals we desire if we dismiss and fail to engage
Republicans and conservatives about the importance of fairness.
WHY WE EXIST
As a party, Democrats have certainly come farther on gay and lesbian issues than Republicans. Log Cabin
has no illusions about this fact. It's why we exist. But, like many in the community, I remember all-too-well the
results of putting all our eggs in one basket. In the early 90s, President Bill Clinton seemed like the brightest
hope for gays and lesbians to ever come along. He wasn't afraid to talk about us, listen to us, and say the
things many of us desperately wanted to hear from our president. Indeed, Democrats helped open some
doors that had remained closed to gay and lesbian Americans. But, it was also the same Democratic
president who signed "Don't Ask, Don't Tell" and the "Defense of Marriage Act"-the two pieces of federal
legislation those of us working for gay rights spend most of our time and resources trying to overturn.
As Melissa Etheridge put it during the much-touted HRC/Logo Democratic presidential forum in August,
many gays felt like they had been "thrown under the bus."
WE NEED A BIPARTISAN MOVEMENT
One way to make sure that doesn't happen again is to demand more from our elected officials. The only way
to do that is to be a truly bi-partisan movement that isn't afraid or unwilling to work with Republicans. As
history shows, when one political party receives the unwavering support of a particular segment of
Americans, they tend to take that group's support for granted. Why do they need to deliver for you? You'll be
there anyway.
Last month, a bi-partisan vote in the U.S. Senate advanced the hate crimes bill. Democrats, of course,
delivered strong results for this important bill. But we must also remember that the bill would not have
passed the Senate unless nine Republicans joined the Democrats in voting for it. Led by Senator Gordon
Smith (R-OR), a vocal ally for gay and lesbian Americans, these nine Republicans provided the margin of
victory that allowed hate crimes to pass.
HERE ARE SOME OTHER EXAMPLES
• ILLINOIS: Currently, a civil unions bill is advancing in Illinois. It recently gained approval in a House
committee, thanks to the tie-breaking vote of Republican State Rep. Elizabeth Coulson. This bill will not
become law unless there is sufficient Republican support.
• NEW YORK: A similar situation faces us in New York where a bill providing marriage equality for same-
sex couples is advancing. Again, the bill will not move through the Senate unless there are enough
Republican votes. Regardless of whether Democrats or Republicans control the state senate in New York,
we're going to need Republican votes for marriage.
• WYOMING: Three Republicans voted against an anti-gay bill in a house committee. It lost by only one
vote.
• MASSACHUSETTS: This spring, our movement achieved one of the greatest and most improbable
victories ever in the fight for LGBT equality. A joint session of the state house and senate rejected a proposed
constitutional ban on same-sex marriage by a vote of 45 to 151. Supporters of the amendment needed only
50 votes to get it on the 2008 ballot. Four House Republicans voted ‘no' and three Senate Republicans voted
‘no.' Without these seven votes, our side would've lost. Republicans helped provide the margin of victory,
showing why a one-party only strategy is the wrong path for the equality movement. We can't win gay rights
victories without votes from both parties.
It is clear that across the country, both at the state level and federally, we must be willing to work with
lawmakers on both sides of the aisle. As we head into one of the most contentious elections in recent
history, I hope our movement remembers that a Democrat-only strategy is a recipe for failure.
Copyright © AMBIENTE MAGAZINE. Do not reproduce without citing this source.
Log Cabin Republicans: One Party Strategy Won't Work
Log Cabin Republicans president explains that Republican support is critical to the LGBT
movement.
by Patrick Sammon
As president of Log Cabin Republicans, the nation's largest
organization of Republicans who support freedom and fairness for
gays and lesbians, I'm not frightened easily. As any gay Republican
can attest, there is a sense of fearlessness that comes with
dispelling myths and assumptions-namely, that being gay and
Republican is somehow an oxy-moron. - Patrick Sammon, LCR
However, as I look to the future political landscape for the LGBT
community, one thing scares me-just a little. It frightens me to
think that some supporters of gay and lesbian equality will
attempt to go down the failed path of pursuing a one-party
strategy toward achieving equality.
REPUBLICAN VOTES ARE NEEDED
As history has shown, particularly in the last fifteen years, the fight for gay and lesbian equality will never be
achieved without Republican votes. We will never reach the goals we desire if we dismiss and fail to engage
Republicans and conservatives about the importance of fairness.
WHY WE EXIST
As a party, Democrats have certainly come farther on gay and lesbian issues than Republicans. Log Cabin
has no illusions about this fact. It's why we exist. But, like many in the community, I remember all-too-well the
results of putting all our eggs in one basket. In the early 90s, President Bill Clinton seemed like the brightest
hope for gays and lesbians to ever come along. He wasn't afraid to talk about us, listen to us, and say the
things many of us desperately wanted to hear from our president. Indeed, Democrats helped open some
doors that had remained closed to gay and lesbian Americans. But, it was also the same Democratic
president who signed "Don't Ask, Don't Tell" and the "Defense of Marriage Act"-the two pieces of federal
legislation those of us working for gay rights spend most of our time and resources trying to overturn.
As Melissa Etheridge put it during the much-touted HRC/Logo Democratic presidential forum in August,
many gays felt like they had been "thrown under the bus."
WE NEED A BIPARTISAN MOVEMENT
One way to make sure that doesn't happen again is to demand more from our elected officials. The only way
to do that is to be a truly bi-partisan movement that isn't afraid or unwilling to work with Republicans. As
history shows, when one political party receives the unwavering support of a particular segment of
Americans, they tend to take that group's support for granted. Why do they need to deliver for you? You'll be
there anyway.
Last month, a bi-partisan vote in the U.S. Senate advanced the hate crimes bill. Democrats, of course,
delivered strong results for this important bill. But we must also remember that the bill would not have
passed the Senate unless nine Republicans joined the Democrats in voting for it. Led by Senator Gordon
Smith (R-OR), a vocal ally for gay and lesbian Americans, these nine Republicans provided the margin of
victory that allowed hate crimes to pass.
HERE ARE SOME OTHER EXAMPLES
• ILLINOIS: Currently, a civil unions bill is advancing in Illinois. It recently gained approval in a House
committee, thanks to the tie-breaking vote of Republican State Rep. Elizabeth Coulson. This bill will not
become law unless there is sufficient Republican support.
• NEW YORK: A similar situation faces us in New York where a bill providing marriage equality for same-
sex couples is advancing. Again, the bill will not move through the Senate unless there are enough
Republican votes. Regardless of whether Democrats or Republicans control the state senate in New York,
we're going to need Republican votes for marriage.
• WYOMING: Three Republicans voted against an anti-gay bill in a house committee. It lost by only one
vote.
• MASSACHUSETTS: This spring, our movement achieved one of the greatest and most improbable
victories ever in the fight for LGBT equality. A joint session of the state house and senate rejected a proposed
constitutional ban on same-sex marriage by a vote of 45 to 151. Supporters of the amendment needed only
50 votes to get it on the 2008 ballot. Four House Republicans voted ‘no' and three Senate Republicans voted
‘no.' Without these seven votes, our side would've lost. Republicans helped provide the margin of victory,
showing why a one-party only strategy is the wrong path for the equality movement. We can't win gay rights
victories without votes from both parties.
It is clear that across the country, both at the state level and federally, we must be willing to work with
lawmakers on both sides of the aisle. As we head into one of the most contentious elections in recent
history, I hope our movement remembers that a Democrat-only strategy is a recipe for failure.
Copyright © AMBIENTE MAGAZINE. Do not reproduce without citing this source.
| RESIDENTIAL COMMERICAL Licensed Across Florida CGC060449 dructorbuilds.com 305-401-8914 |
| GAY & LESBIAN ALLIANCE AGAINST DEFAMATION WWW.GLAAD.ORG |
| Gay American Heroes Foundation Honoring LGBT persons who died because of their sexual orientation and gender identity www.gayamericanheroes.com |
| Endulge Yourself... Chocolate Themed Baskets & Gifts www.dulcestore.com |
| Web resource for LGBTQ youth www.matthewsplace.com |
| An online forum on sexual health education for gay and bisexual men www.lifelube.org |
| www.familiasporladiversidad.org |
| LIGA Contra el SIDA - SoFla. League Against AIDS www.leagueagainstaids.org |
